Case Study
When Empathy Moves Strategy
Transcending Obstacles With Human Stories
When Data Shows the Problem but Not the Stakes
Overcoming obstacles to change is one of the most common failure points of many strategic execution. Power dynamics keep crucial conversations from happening. Insights may surface but rarely stick. Resistance lives not only in systems, but in habits and relationships.
As I convened a strategic retreat of more than 80 leaders, I expected we’d face these same hurdles. The goal: decide whether to expand a care management program for patients who frequently visited the emergency department. Around each table sat board members, executives, and physician leaders — seasoned professionals who already knew the data: a small group of vulnerable patients driving a disproportionate number of visits and admissions.
Yet something was missing. The data showed what was happening, not why it mattered.
Seeing Beyond the Data
The real challenge wasn’t statistical — it was emotional. Decision-makers doubted whether the hospital could truly help patients whose struggles began at home, between hospital visits. Many questioned whether interventions would last or whether these patients could change.
We realized logic alone wouldn’t move the room. What was needed was empathy — a way for leaders to feel the lived experience behind the data.
To bridge that gap, a nurse from our care management team visited three patients from the pilot program. With only a $160 digital camera and her own compassion, she recorded short videos capturing what it’s like to live with chronic illness, navigate fragmented care, and feel unseen by the system. The videos were unfiltered and real — told entirely in the patients’ own words.
Empathy in Action
When the topic came up at the retreat, we didn’t start with slide decks. We started with the stories.
One video, in particular, struck a chord — Jack’s. Overweight, depressed, and tethered to oxygen, he hadn’t been out of bed alone in two years. A physician stood and pointed at the screen: “I know that guy. He’s noncompliant. He doesn’t do what we tell him. He’s a lost cause.” Others nodded in agreement.
Then a board member stood. Quietly, firmly, she said the health system had failed Jack — and the others on the screen. “We can do better.”
The temperature in the room changed. Conversation shifted from defensiveness to ownership. Physicians began proposing solutions. The data was revisited not as numbers, but as evidence of people we could serve better.
Purpose Becomes Policy
With renewed purpose, the board voted to launch the program.
The pilot team doubled in size to include a nurse practitioner, registered nurses, social workers, and care coordinators. The model was grounded in evidence and guided by validated assessment tools.
The goals were clear and measurable: reduce readmissions and length of stay while improving patients’ self-management skills and quality of life. Outcomes would be tracked against a control group, reported to the board, and reviewed by its quality committee.
Results That Spoke for Themselves
Over the next several years, the program consistently met its goals. Hospitalizations dropped 40% compared to the control group. Patients reported a two-fold improvement in quality-of-life scores and a six-fold increase in self-care confidence.
One year later, at the following retreat, leaders revisited the data — and Jack’s story. With the team’s support, he was walking again, driving one of his beloved cars, and rebuilding his relationship with his daughter. He had sold his home to move closer to her. “I’m grateful,” he said in a message to his nurse. “I’m finally in control of my life.”
The Lasting Power of Human Understanding
At Shift Group Consulting, we’ve seen again and again how human stories transcend the obstacles of hierarchy, systems, and habit. Data informs — but stories inspire. These moments of empathy create alignment that endures. They are told and retold, shaping culture long after the retreat ends.
An inexpensive camera. A free video editor. A nurse willing to listen.
That’s the power of human understanding.
That’s how empathy becomes strategy.
Want a Clearer Starting Point?
If you’re preparing to launch a new strategy — or wondering why execution feels harder than it should — start with a Shift Diagnostic. You’ll gain clarity, confidence, and a precise roadmap for where to focus next.